Community Health Journal

Community Health Journal

Comparing the Effectiveness of Combined Therapy (Emotional Focused Couple & Reality Therapy) with Schema Therapy on Marital Satisfaction in Heterogeneous and Conflicting Couples: A Single Case Study

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
A Berdi-Khoje 1
A Jahangiri 2
A Mafakheri 3
1 PhD Student, Dept of Psychology, Bojnourd Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bojnourd, Iran.
2 Assistant Prof, Dept of Psychology and Counseling, Payame-Noor University, Tehran. Iran.
3 Assistant Prof, Dept of Psychology, Payame-Noor University, Tehran. Iran.
10.22123/chj.2023.347016.1909
Abstract
Introduction: Marital satisfaction is one of the variables easily affected by the relationship between couples. Statistics show an increase in divorce due to marital dissatisfaction. Therefore, this study compared the effectiveness of combined therapy with schema therapy on marital satisfaction in heterogeneous and conflicting couples.
Materials and Methods: The research was a single case study with pre-test, post-test, and follow-up design. The statistical population included conflicting couples referred to the Parsa counseling clinic in Bandar-e-Torkmen County in 2021. Among them, six couples (husband and wife) were selected based on the research entry criteria, structured clinical interview, and marital satisfaction questionnaire (Olson et al., 1987) using purposive sampling. The subjects of the two groups of combined therapy and schema therapy received 12 weekly sessions (two sessions, 90 minutes each) separately. Descriptive statistics, Chi-squared test, visual analysis of graph with reliable change index (RCI≥ 1.96), and recovery percentage were used in the results report.
Results: The findings of the research showed that both methods of integrated treatment and schema therapy had made statistically and clinically significant changes in the treatment goals (p<0.05), and the therapeutic effects continued in the follow-up period (RCI≥ 1.96). However, the percentage of recovery in the combined therapy group (PND=38.70 & p=0.018) was higher than in the schema therapy group (PND=27.45 & p=0.024).
Conclusion: Combined therapy was effective in increasing the marital satisfaction of couples; thus, it can be used in medical centers to improve family and marital function.
Keywords
Single case study
Combined therapy
Schema therapy
Marital satisfaction
  1. Frye-Cox N, Ganong L, Jensen T, Coleman M. Marital conflict and health: the moderating roles of emotion regulation and marriage order. Journal of Divorce & Remarriage 2021; 62(6):450-74.
  2. Dong S, Dong Q, Chen H. Mothers' parenting stress, depression, marital conflict, and marital satisfaction: The moderating effect of fathers' empathy tendency. JAD 2022; 299: 682-90.
  3. Meyer D, Sledge R. The relationship between conflict topics and romantic relationship dynamics. JFEI 2022; 43(2):306-23.
  4. Yoo G, Joo S. Love for a marriage story: the association between love and marital satisfaction in middle adulthood. JCFS 2022; 31(6):1570-81.
  5. Wiley E, Khattab S, Tang A. Examining the effect of virtual reality therapy on cognition post-stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Disability and Rehabilitation: Assistive Technology 2022; 17(1):50-60.
  6. Glasser W. Promoting client strength through positive addiction. CJCP 2012; 11(4):123-39.
  7. An U, Park HG, Han DE, Kim YH. Emotional suppression and psychological well-being in marriage: the role of regulatory focus and spousal behavior. IJERPH 2022; 19(2):973-90.
  8. Page SJ. Religion and intimate life: marriage, family, sexuality. in the routledge handbook of religion, gender and society. Routledge 2022; 234-48.
  9. Johnson SM. The emotionally focused couple therapy. 2nd Translated by: Bahrami F, Azarian Z, Etemadi O. Tehran: arjmand 2022.
  10. Dos Santos LM. The attitudes and experiences of marriage and family counselors for same-sex couple and family clients: a qualitative study. JESR 2022; 12(1):24-36.
  11. Wibbelink CJ, Arntz A, Grasman RP, Sinnaeve R, Boog M, Bremer O, et al. Towards optimal treatment selection for borderline personality disorder patients (BOOTS): a study protocol for a multicenter randomized clinical trial comparing schema therapy and dialectical behavior therapy. BMC psychiatry 2022; 22(1):1-28.
  12. Bernstein DP, Wijk-Herbrink MFV, Kersten T. Forensic schema therapy and safe-path: individual-and milieu-therapy approaches for complex personality disorders and externalizing behavior problems. in clinical forensic psychology. Palgrave Macmillan, Cham 2022; pp:587-608.
  13. Young JE, Klosko JS, Weishaar ME. Schema therapy: a practitioners’ guide. 5nd Translated by: Hamidpour H, Andouz Z. Tehran: ARJMAND 2022. [Persian]
  14. Farahani HA, Abedi A, Aghamohammadi S, Kazemi Z. Methodology of single case series in behavioural sciences and medicine. 3nd Tehran: Danzhe; 2019: 23-59. [Persian]
  15. Kazdin AE. Single-Case Research Designs: Methods for Clinical and Applied Settings. 3nd Oxford University Press 2020; pp:211.
  16. Doherty WJ, Kalantar SM, Tarsafi M. Divorce Ambivalence and Reasons for Divorce in Iran. Family Process 2021; 60(1):159-68.
  17. First MB, Gibbon M. The structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis I disorders (SCID I) and the structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis II disorders (SCID II). In: Hisenroth MJ, Segal DL, editors. Comprehensive handbook of psychological assessment, Personality assessment, 2nd New Jersey: Wiley; 2004: 134-43.
  18. Fowers BJ, Olson DH. ENRICH Marital Satisfaction Scale: A brief research and clinical tool. Journal of Family psychology 1993; 7(2):176-85.
  19. Behrouz B, GolMohammadian M, HojatKhah SM. The causal relationship between emotion regulation and suicidal ideation mediated by marital satisfaction in earthquake-stricken women.AFTJ 2021; 2(1):91-107. [Persian]
  20. Jejeebhoy SJ, Raushan MR. Marriage without meaningful consent and compromised agency in married life: evidence from married girls in Jharkhand, India. Journal of Adolescent Health 2022; 70(3):78-85.
  21. Alizade A, Isanejad O. Comparing the effectiveness of couples coping enhancement training (CCET) and TOGETHER program on marital stress and marital satisfaction of couples. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology 2022; 22(4):134-49. [Persian]
  22. El Frenn Y, Akel M, Hallit S, Obeid S. Couple’s satisfaction among lebanese adults: validation of the Toronto alexithymia scale and couple satisfaction index-4 scales, association with attachment styles and mediating role of alexithymia. BMC psychol 2022; 10(1):1-10.
  23. Righetti F, Faure R, Zoppolat G, Meltzer A, McNulty J. Factors that contribute to the maintenance or decline of relationship satisfaction. Nature Reviews Psychology 2022; 1(3):161-73.
  24. Ece EKEN, Çankaya ZC. The relationship between early maladaptive schemas and psychological tendencies associated with the romantic relationships in university students: an investigation through the schema therapy model. C.U Faculty of Education Journal 2022; 51(1):689-717.
  25. Mirabi M, Hafezi F, Mehrabizadeh Honarmand M, Naderi F, Ehtesham Zadeh P. The comparison effect of emotion-oriented schema therapy and solution-focused brief therapy (SFBT) on marital intimacy in women with marital conflicts referring to psychological centers. Women's Studies, Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies 2021; 12(35):239-56. [Persian]
  26. Moridi H, Kajbaf MB, Mahmoodi A. The Effectof Islamic-Ianian Reality Therapy on Couples’ Marital Satisfaction, Life Satisfaction, and Communication Skills Shiraz. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology 2020; 21(2):13-21. [Persian]
  27. Hosseini Z, TajicEsmaeili A, MohsenZadeh F. The effect of teaching the concepts of the choice theory on marital attitude in marring people according to attachment style. Knowledge & Research in Applied Psychology 2022; 22(4):43-57. [Persian]
  28. Panahifar S, Momeni A. The effectiveness of couple therapy based on emotional intelligence components on reducing marital conflicts and increasing adjustment of divorce applicant couples. Shenakht 2021; 8(4):38-50. [Persian]
  29. Kailanko S, Wiebe SA, Tasca GA, Laitila AA. Impact of repeating somatic cues on the depth of experiencing for withdrawers and pursuers in emotionally focused couple therapy. JMFT 2022; 48(3):693-708.
  30. Doss BD, Roddy MK, Wiebe SA, Johnson SM. A review of the research during 2010-2019 on evidence‐based treatments for couple relationship distress. JMFT 2022; 48(1):283-
  31. Masumi Tabar Z, Afshariniya K, Amiri H, Hosseini SA. The effectiveness of emotional schema therapy on emotional regulation problems and marital satisfaction of maladaptive women of the first decade of life. JPS 2021; 19(95):1497-506. [Persian]
  32. IsmaeilZadeh N, Akbari B. The effectiveness of schema therapy on sexual self-efficacy, marital satisfaction and early maladaptive schemas in couples with marital conflicts. MJMS 2021; 64(1):2286-98. [Persian]
  33. Ahmadzadehaghdam E, Karimisani P, Goudarzi M, Moradi O. The effectiveness of couple therapy with schema therapy approach on disaffection and marital commitment in couples. IJPN 2020; 8(5):1-13. [Persian]